Head-to-Head Comparison

Energizer Auto-On LED Rechargeable vs NITECORE MH12 Pro

Side-by-side specs, scores, and Amazon pricing. Winner badges show which model leads each profile. Full spec comparison is included below.

Winner by Profile

Spec
Beam Pattern
Price & Scores2
Price$26$80
MSRP$31$90
Output & Beam7
Max Lumens1 lm3,300 lm
Sustained Lumens1,100 lm
Peak Candela63,800 cd
Beam Distance505 m
Beam Patternhybridthrow
IP RatingIPX4IP68
Impact Resistance1.0 m1.0 m
Runtime3
Runtime (High)140 min
Runtime (500lm)190 min
Turbo Stepdown120 s
Physical5
Weight168 g
Length142 mm
Head Diameter34.0 mm
Body Diameter25.4 mm
Body MaterialPolymerAluminum
Battery & Charging6
Battery Type21700
Chargingusb-cusb-c
USB-CNoYes
Replaceable BatteryNoYes
Battery IncludedNoNo
Rechargeable BatteryNoYes
Features7
Switch Typesidedual
Strobe ModeNoYes
Memory ModeNoYes
LockoutNoYes
Moonlight ModeNoYes
Magnetic TailcapNoNo
Pocket ClipNoYes
Checklist9
Impact Resistant
Waterproof
USB-C Rechargeable
Battery Replaceable
Strobe Mode
Memory Mode
Lockout
Magnetic Tailcap
Pocket Clip
Emitter & Optics1
LED / EmitterLuminus SFT70
Category Scores5
Tactical Score74.585.6
EDC Score85.784.2
Value Score97.086.3
Throw Score78.688.0
Flood Score82.585.7
Amazon3
Amazon Reviews16,7701,200
Amazon Rating4.74.6
Release Year2,0212,023

Our Verdict

The Energizer Auto-On LED Rechargeable takes the edge with a stronger value profile (97.0 vs 88.0). It's the better pick for value use. The NITECORE MH12 Pro may still be worth considering for throw applications.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Pricing and availability can change quickly. Always use Check Price on Amazon for current details.